Wednesday, September 02, 2009

Upcoming Pycon and crst2s5

In a few months, many pythonistas will be converging to Atlanta to take part in the next Pycon.  I'm hoping to be able to attend it as I have been really inspired by the many people I met in two previous conferences.  While I most likely won't be presenting anything this time, I thought I would try to contribute to some presentations in an indirect way.

A while ago, Ned Batchelder wrote about presentation tools - more specifically about how he found all of them lacking.  In the comments section, many people made various suggestions - including one suggestion by Steve Holden which read as follows:


HTML plus live Python - what could be better?
While I, of course, approve of any positive support of Crunchy, I had to admit to myself (and mention in a subsequent comment) that Crunchy was really not up to the task - at least not yet.

In his post, Ned addresses some of the weaknesses of the tools he looked at.  In particular, he mentioned S5 about which he wrote:

S5 (A Simple Standards-Based Slide Show System) is all HTML, CSS, and Javascript, runs in the browser, and was created by Eric Meyer, a very nice pedigree. Remarkably, the thing I like least about it is that when I display the slides in a full-screen Firefox, they look horrible. The text is either too small or too large, and the line-spacing too tight, while the slide title overlaps the text in the wrong way, exposing some of the structure of the divs.
I would have hoped that a CSS-based slideshow by the king of CSS would be a shining example of how information could be cleanly authored and then sparklingly displayed. S5 seems to miss this mark, especially since there don't seem to be many themes available for it, another surprise given how CSS should have made it accessible to lots of designers. Also, although (or perhaps because) the format is native to the web, it's not possible to get the slides as illustrations.
Still, S5 is used for quite a few presentations by pythonistas thank to rst2s5, the docutils script that transform reStructuredText files into S5 presentations.  If I can summarize, rst2s5 strengths are as follow:

  • uses reStructuredText as source - easier to write than html
  • produce html files - thus easy to post and share -see link above.
  • use well known S5 slides (version 1.1 designed by Eric Meyer) to switch between "full paper"/slides.  It is possible to include extra notes in the "full paper".
Some of the weaknesses are the following:
  • From rst2s5's own documentation, it is impossible to have:
     - speaker's notes on the laptop screen
     - slides on the projector
     - two views stay in sync
     - presentation controlled from either display
  • like most (all?) slide-based presentation, content on one slide is limited to a given number of lines ... which makes it ackward to show long-ish code samples.
  • as Ned Batchelder alludes to, the automatic scaling done by S5 often yields unsatisfactory results in terms of line spacing, etc.
  • Finally, no interactive Python code in presentation ;-)

rst2s5 is based on S5 version 1.1.  A new version (1.2 alpha) is available which addresses some of the shortcomings of version 1.1 with the addition of speaker's notes which are in a separate window (e.g. on the laptop screen) while the slides themselves are in a different window (which can be on the projector) with the two synchronized.

I have decided to hack at the source (I don't like javascript...) and adapt S5 1.2 in ways which address some of Ned Batchelder's criticisms about the line spacing, etc, by disabling the automatic font scaling.  I incorporated it in a new program called crst2s5 which can be thought of as a Crunchy-extension to rst2s5.  crst2s5 on its own can produce standalone presentations (like rst2s5).  I consider it to be an improvement to rst2s5 ... time will tell if others share my opinion.

However, where crst2s5 can yield really interesting results is when you view the html output with Crunchy.  For now (version 1.1), when you do so, the automatic synchronization of speaker notes and slides is disabled - this will be addressed hopefully in the near future.   You can either try it by downloading the code or have a look at this sneak preview which I put together in one quick take as an experiment:

Get the Flash Player to see this movie.

Original location: 'Crunchy'
at ShowMeDo from the Python category.

Now, if only I had better graphical skills to design good looking slides...

No comments: