As part of the additional motivation for my experiment, I mentioned the following:
In one of his posts to python-ideas, Terry Jan Reddy mentioned a discussion on the idle-dev list about making idle friendlier to beginners. In one of his post, he mentioned the idea of having non-English keywords. This idea is not new. There already exists an unmaintained version with Chinese Keywords as well as a Lithuanian and Russion version. Maintaining a version based on a different language for keywords is surely not something simple ... nor I think it would be desirable. However, it might be possible to essentially achieve the same goal by using an approach I describe in the next section.
Even just adding new keywords can be quite difficult. For example, in this post, Eli Bendersky explains how one can add a new keyword to Python. "All" you ned to do is
- Modify the grammar to add the new keyword
- Modify the AST generation code; this requires a knowledge of C
- Compile the AST into bytecode
- Recompile the modified Python interpreter
Not exactly for the faint of heart...
I thought I should revisit the idea I had to see how difficult it might be to create a French Python syntax. As it turned out, it was even simpler than implementing a new keyword. In addition to the code mentioned previously, the new function needed is simply:
def transform_source_code(text):
dictionary = {...}
toks = tokenize.generate_tokens(StringIO(text).readline)
result = []
result = []
for toktype, tokvalue, _, _, _ in toks:
if toktype == tokenize.NAME and tokvalue in dictionary:
result.append((toktype, dictionary[tokvalue]))
else:
result.append((toktype, tokvalue))
return tokenize.untokenize(result)
where the dictionary contains the equivalent (e.g. "Vrai": "True", etc.)
The one change I made from the previous version was to replace __experimental__ by __nonstandard__.
For example, here's a test program:
from __nonstandard__ import french_syntax
de math importe pi
imprime(pi)
imprime("The first 5 odd integers are:")
pour i dans intervalle(1, 11, 2):
imprime(i)
imprime("This should be false:", Vrai et Faux)
si pi == 3:
imprime("We must be in Indiana")
ousi pi > 4:
print("Non standard Euclidean space")
autrement:
print("There should be nothing about Indiana nor Euclidean space.")
de math importe pi
imprime(pi)
imprime("The first 5 odd integers are:")
pour i dans intervalle(1, 11, 2):
imprime(i)
imprime("This should be false:", Vrai et Faux)
si pi == 3:
imprime("We must be in Indiana")
ousi pi > 4:
print("Non standard Euclidean space")
autrement:
print("There should be nothing about Indiana nor Euclidean space.")
The code found in version 5 of this repository. Using this approach, it would be trivial to create localized Python versions suitable to introduce absolute beginners to programming concepts. I would not do this myself, here in Canada, but I could see the appeal in some other countries especially those where the English alphabet is not very well known by young learners.
Now, if only I could figure out how to use importlib instead of imp ...
Now, if only I could figure out how to use importlib instead of imp ...
No comments:
Post a Comment